Motus Aquaticus

<br><br>

recent posts

about

Which Scuba Agencies Require SAC Rate Calculations, Turn Pressure, and Reserve Planning in Their Open Water Programs?

Which Scuba Agencies Require SAC Rate Calculations, Turn Pressure, and Reserve Planning in Their Open Water Programs?

If you’re looking for an Open Water scuba certification that mandates the teaching of SAC rate calculations, turn pressure, and reserve planning, only a few agencies integrate these detailed gas management skills into their entry-level programs. Most recreational scuba courses focus on basic air monitoring, but some agencies—particularly those with a technical diving emphasis—require students to master these concepts from the start. Below, I’ll outline which agencies fully meet these criteria, explain what these terms mean, and highlight how they’re taught, based on practices as of March 15, 2025.

Understanding the Key Concepts

Before diving into the agencies, here’s a quick breakdown of what we’re looking for:

  • SAC Rate (Surface Air Consumption): A calculation of how much breathing gas you use per minute at the surface (e.g., in psi/min or cu ft/min), which is then adjusted for depth using ATA (atmospheres absolute) to plan gas needs underwater.
  • Turn Pressure: The gas pressure at which you stop exploring and begin your return or ascent, calculated based on consumption and reserves (e.g., using the Rule of Thirds or specific dive profiles).
  • Reserve Planning: Setting aside a specific amount of emergency gas (e.g., Rock Bottom) to ensure you and a buddy can ascend safely, including time for safety stops and potential delays.

The article focus is on agencies that require these skills to be taught, so we’ll focus on those that mandate detailed instruction and practical application in their Open Water programs.

Agencies That Fully Meet the Criteria

Only two agencies consistently require SAC rate calculations, turn pressure, and reserve planning as core components of their Open Water-level training: GUE (Global Underwater Explorers) and UTD (Unified Team Diving). Here’s how they do it:

1. GUE – Fundamentals

  • Course Overview: 5–7 days, 6–8 dives (pool + open water).
  • SAC Rate Calculations:
    • Students measure their personal SAC rate during pool sessions (e.g., 15 psi/min at rest).
    • They learn to adjust this rate for depth using the formula: SAC × ATA (e.g., at 66 ft/20 m, 3 ATA, a 15 psi/min SAC becomes 45 psi/min).
  • Turn Pressure:
    • Taught using the Rule of Thirds: For a 3000 psi tank, 1000 psi is used outbound, 1000 psi for the return, and 1000 psi is reserved (adjusted based on dive specifics).
    • Students calculate precise turn pressures based on depth, time, and SAC rate.
  • Reserve Planning:
    • Requires Rock Bottom calculations: the minimum gas needed for two divers to ascend safely from depth (e.g., 1000 psi from 66 ft), including ascent rate (30 ft/min) and a 3-minute safety stop.
    • Practical drills (e.g., valve failures, air sharing) ensure real-world application.
  • Why It Qualifies: GUE’s technical focus makes gas planning a foundational skill. SAC rate, turn pressure, and reserves are taught with precision and reinforced through hands-on practice.

2. UTD – Open Water

  • Course Overview: 5–7 days, 6–8 dives (pool + open water).
  • SAC Rate Calculations:
    • Students calculate their SAC rate (e.g., 0.5 cu ft/min) during training dives.
    • Depth adjustments are taught using ATA (e.g., at 33 ft/10 m, 2 ATA, a 0.5 cu ft/min SAC becomes 1 cu ft/min).
  • Turn Pressure:
    • Determined using ratio deco principles, tying gas consumption to time and depth (e.g., for a 3000 psi tank, turn at 1500 psi based on the planned profile).
    • Calculations factor in SAC rate and dive objectives.
  • Reserve Planning:
    • Students compute emergency reserves (e.g., Rock Bottom) for two divers to ascend, including safety stops (e.g., 1000 psi from a given depth).
    • Team-based scenarios test these plans in action.
  • Why It Qualifies: UTD’s tech-driven curriculum ensures SAC rate, turn pressure, and reserve planning are mandatory, preparing divers for advanced gas management from day one.

Agencies That Partially Include These Skills

Some agencies introduce these concepts but don’t fully require detailed calculations or consistent application. Here’s how they stack up:

3. RAID – Open Water

  • Course Overview: 2–3 days, 4–5 dives (pool + open water), e-learning.
  • SAC Rate: Introduced as a concept—students learn to monitor consumption but aren’t required to calculate SAC rates (e.g., psi/min) or adjust for depth.
  • Turn Pressure: Suggested as a basic guideline (e.g., turn at half tank + reserve, like 1000 psi), but not tied to detailed SAC-based calculations.
  • Reserve Planning: Teaches a simple reserve (e.g., 500–700 psi), not a comprehensive Rock Bottom calculation.
  • Why It Falls Short: While RAID’s tech-leaning approach touches on these ideas, it doesn’t mandate full SAC rate calculations or detailed planning.

4. SDI – Open Water

  • Course Overview: 2–4 days, 4–5 dives (pool + open water), e-learning/class.
  • SAC Rate: Mentioned—students use dive computers to track consumption, but detailed SAC calculations (e.g., cu ft/min) aren’t required.
  • Turn Pressure: Taught as a basic rule (e.g., “turn at 1000 psi”), not calculated using SAC rates.
  • Reserve Planning: Emphasizes a simple reserve (e.g., 500 psi), not a detailed two-diver ascent plan.
  • Why It Falls Short: SDI introduces gas awareness, but the lack of mandatory SAC calculations and in-depth planning keeps it partial.

5. NAUI – Open Water Scuba Diver

  • Course Overview: 3–5 days, 5–7 dives (pool + open water).
  • SAC Rate: May be taught (e.g., psi/min) by some instructors, but it’s not a universal requirement.
  • Turn Pressure: Often covered (e.g., turn at half tank + reserve), but methods vary by instructor.
  • Reserve Planning: Basic reserves (e.g., 500 psi) might be included, but detailed Rock Bottom calculations aren’t standard.
  • Why It Falls Short: NAUI’s instructor flexibility means these skills can be taught but aren’t consistently required across all courses.

Agencies That Don’t Meet the Criteria

Most recreational agencies—PADI, SSI, CMAS, BSAC, and SEI—don’t require SAC rate calculations, turn pressure, or reserve planning in their Open Water programs. Instead, they focus on basic air monitoring (e.g., “turn at 1000 psi, surface with 500 psi”) without detailed calculations. These programs prioritize simplicity and accessibility over technical gas management, making them unsuitable for this articles focus.

Summary of Findings

Fully Qualifying Agencies

  • GUE Fundamentals:
    • SAC Rate: Calculated (e.g., 15 psi/min × ATA).
    • Turn Pressure: Rule of Thirds (e.g., 1000 psi segments).
    • Reserve: Rock Bottom (e.g., 1000 psi for two divers).
  • UTD Open Water:
    • SAC Rate: Calculated (e.g., 0.5 cu ft/min × ATA).
    • Turn Pressure: Ratio deco-based (e.g., 1500 psi turn).
    • Reserve: Detailed emergency gas (e.g., 1000 psi).

Partially Qualifying Agencies

  • RAID: Introduces SAC awareness, basic turn pressure, and simple reserves—no full calculations.
  • SDI: Covers consumption via computers, basic turn pressure, and reserves—no detailed SAC or planning.
  • NAUI: Can include all three, but it’s inconsistent and instructor-dependent.

Recommendation

For an Open Water program that requires SAC rate calculations, turn pressure, and reserve planning, GUE Fundamentals and UTD Open Water are the clear leaders. Both mandate these skills with detailed instruction and practical application, setting a strong foundation for technical diving. If you’re considering RAID, SDI, or NAUI, be aware that their coverage is less comprehensive or consistent. Let me know where you’re diving or what your goals are—I can tailor this further!

Posted in

Leave a comment